Brazil meat scandal: trade hits back after police sting

Industry associations warn the Brazilian meat scandal could lead to job losses

After a major investigation showed evidence of rotten meat being consumed in Brazil and exported over the last two years, Brazilian meatpacking industry associations have accused the police of exaggeration.

Speaking at a press conference in São Paulo, on Monday (20 March), Francisco Sergio Turra, head of the Brazilian Association of Animal Proteins (ABPA - Associação Brasileira de Proteína Animal), said the country’s meat production standards followed international models. ABPA represents the poultry and pork industries in Brazil.

Turra spoke out after the launch, three days ago, of a federal police operation dubbed ‘Weak Meat’, which officers claimed detected irregularities within 29 Brazilian companies, among them two of the biggest meatpackers in the world: JBS and BRF. Both have already denied any wrongdoing. The police allege that Brazilian meat companies have been bribing 33 officials from Brazil’s Ministry of Agriculture, Livestock and Food Supply, allowing companies to operate without proper surveillance. All those inspectors were removed from office on Monday 20 March.

Turra, however, is unhappy at the bad publicity and how it has tarnished the reputation of the whole industry: “The way this police raid was communicated has aroused generalisations,” he said, adding that Brazil’s federal government and industry associations needed to clarify to consumers in Brazil and abroad that Brazilian meat producers had high standards. He stressed that his colleagues had not gone to the capital Brasilia “to protest against the police [and] we are not speaking out against anyone”. He declared: “Our main concern is the six million workers of the industry. We are on a patriotic mission.

Seriously damage trade

Brazil exports a wide range of meat products to 160 countries, which represents 15% of Brazilian exports, being particularly strong in poultry, bovine and pigmeat.

The scandal has the potential to seriously damage this trade, with regulators for major markets, including China and the European Union (EU), announcing today that they are suspending imports of Brazilian meat.

Also speaking at the press conference, Antônio Jorge Camardelli, head of the Brazilian Association of the Exporting Meat Industries (ABIEC - Associação Brasileira das Indústrias Exportadoras de Carne), said the police raids had created “an unnecessary crisis”. ABIEC represents 91% of Brazil’s bovine meat exporting industry.

Job losses

We built our reputation little by little. The opening of markets abroad was slow, country by country. Today Brazilian meatpacking industries have the best excellence certifications,” Camardelli said. “Restrictions will impact all the economy and lead to the loss of jobs and income.

ABPA and ABIEC also printed a joint statement in Brazil’s best-selling newspapers, saying it was irresponsible for actions and statements to raise doubts about the overall quality of Brazilian meat. Brazil’s federal police did not reply to requests for comment from this site.

We, together, can give consumers in Brazil and abroad an assurance that they can consume meats produced in our country with confidence about their sanitary quality,” Camardelli said.

Related News

Four Brazilian slaughterhouses have been banned from selling meat to Europe

Brazil meat scandal: EU says trade ban ‘inaccurate’

Copa-Cogeca wants to see tougher import controls after the Brazilian meat scandal

Farm body wants ‘action’ after Brazil meat scandal

The European Commission will audit Brazil's meat supply chain by mid-May

Leaders from Brazil and EU to tackle meat 'crisis'

Brazil said it was 'grateful China, Chile and Egypt have lifted meat import bans

Key markets lift ban on Brazilian meat

Brazil's agriculture minister Blairo Maggi said the move is 'good news' for meat exporters

Hong Kong restores Brazilian meat trade

Brazil's beef industry is adamant that the meat scandal won't hurt export growth

Brazil standing by export hope as meat scandal cools

A diplomatic offensive from Brazil's president Michel Temer eased the meat scandal

Brazil meat scandal could spark billions in losses

Brazil's meat is safe to eat and does not pose a public health risk, according to government officials

No health risk from Brazil’s meat scandal, says envoy

Watch: Brazil meat scandal

Meat business BRF said it has 'confidence' in its food safety standards

Brazilian meat plant targeted in corruption probe reopens

Petition organisers attacked the 'fat cat meatpackers' who, they claim, undercut US beef

US petition seeks to ban Brazilian beef imports

JBS CEO Wesley Batista said South America faced 'a challenging scenario'

JBS posts poor income amid bribery investigation

Federal police believe the Agriculture Ministry received millions of Brazilian reals in bribes

Brazil police probe ‘corruption’ in agriculture ministry

Brazil President Michel Temer gave a defiant speech amid a growing corruption crisis

Brazil President Temer hits out at JBS chief

JBS stopped buying cattle from the farm after links to slave labour surfaced

JBS dropped slavery-linked supplier a year ago

Many countries had initially banned imports of Brazilian beef, only to reinstate trade

US suspends imports of Brazilian beef

It is unclear at this stage if Brazil will face export bans as a result of the meat scandal

Brazil rocked by rotten meat scandal

The meat industry in Brazil could become the largest protein exporter in ten years

Brazil’s billion-dollar meat industry faces price and health pressures

Plumrose USA CEO Dave Schanzer said the JBS takeover is 'exciting news'

Brazil's JBS moves on Danish Crown US outfit

The Brazil delegation will visit farms and factories in Vladimir Oblast

Brazil sends inspectors to endorse Russian meat plant

Brazilian beef exporters will charge forward with growth plans for the Middle East this year

China’s hunger for Brazilian beef eases drop

Loss-making BRF said sales of flagship brand Sadia performed well in the Middle East

Brazilian meat giant ‘dissatisfied’ after loss

Naproxen is banned in EU meat products for human consumption

Belgium horsemeat call after drug found in Brazilian imports

BRF: foodservice remains an integral pillar of European expansion plans

Brazilian meat giant's foodservice web drive

BRF said Turkey is one of the world's largest poultry markets for halal meat

BRF to buy Turkey’s Banvit in $470m venture

BRF's Sadia, launched in 1944, was recently voted Brazil's third most valuable brand

BRF promotes flagship brand Sadia in Hungary

Related Products

See more related products

Comments (2)

Afham Farook - 22 Mar 2017 | 09:08

Beef & poultry scandal

Exageration ? Really ??

22-Mar-2017 at 09:08 GMT

Andrew McNeil - 21 Mar 2017 | 02:31


These companies should have thought before bribing officials or using infredients non-approved or above the limits. That's anothe big blow for the processed meat business worldwide...

21-Mar-2017 at 14:31 GMT

Submit a comment

Your comment has been saved

Post a comment

Please note that any information that you supply is protected by our Privacy and Cookie Policy. Access to all documents and request for further information are available to all users at no costs, In order to provide you with this free service, William Reed Business Media SAS does share your information with companies that have content on this site. When you access a document or request further information from this site, your information maybe shared with the owners of that document or information.